The conversation goes something like this:
Jude: What color Margot's eyes? Black.
Mommy: Well, yes, they are black, but they are also blue.
Jude: What color Susie and Joe's eyes?
Mommy: Hmmm... I think they have brown eyes.
I lean forward towards Jude and ask: Hey Jude - what color are Mommy's eyes?
Mommy: Yes, Jude. That's correct. Mommy has red eyes.